Using a Transducer for speed vs. GPS speed

Question

​Do I need a paddle wheel type transducer for speed if I have a GPS unit?

Solution

​The paddle wheel calculates your "speed through the water" by monitoring the paddle wheel RPM.  The GPS receiver calculates your "speed over ground" by comparing previous position fixes over time.
 
It's important to understand that these sensors provide different types of speed data.  Generally speaking, GPS speed is more representative of a vessel's "actual speed", since it calculates speed based on distance traveled and time to travel this distance.  The paddle wheel calculates your "speed through water" by monitoring the RPM of the paddle wheel.  Paddle wheel speed is affected by currents, tides, vessel movement, etc., and it doesn't always indicate your "actual" speed.  
 
For example:  a vessel cruising on a smooth lake during a calm day may experience GPS and paddle wheel speeds that are nearly identical.   However, a  vessel traveling upstream in a river with a 6-knot current will probably see a significant difference between the GPS and paddle wheel speeds. The (GPS) speed over ground could be 5 knots, while the (paddle wheel) speed through water will probably read about 11 knots.  This is because the paddlewheel is sensing a "relative" speed of 11 knots.  (The 5-knot forward speed of the vessel is essentially "added" to the 6-knot current that the vessel is heading into). 
 
Many fishermen and boating enthusiasts want access to both GPS (speed over ground) and paddle wheel (speed through water) data on their vessel.